coherence_review · supabase_json

Oro Docs MCP coherence_review

coherence_review artifact · for Oro Docs MCP · status draft

Planning Surface

Use this to decide what happens next.

Status

draft

decision

notes

Proceed to DECOMP and PLAN. No implementation until EXEC_PLAN_REVIEW approves a build slice.

ready for build

false

ready for decomp

true

build requires exec approval

true

Agent Handoff

Start Here

coherence_review artifact · for Oro Docs MCP · status draft

Completion Evidence

No explicit evidence field yet. Require tests, screenshots, linked PRs, or reviewed outputs before marking complete.

Decision

notes: Proceed to DECOMP and PLAN. No implementation until EXEC_PLAN_REVIEW approves a build slice.
ready for build: false
ready for decomp: true
build requires exec approval: true

Structured Payload

Machine-readable source fields

checks

id	name	status	finding
CHK-001	Project Classification	pass	Artifacts consistently classify this as an internal tooling project, not an Oro product implementation or public documentation fork.
CHK-002	Source Ownership	pass	Oro repositories remain sibling checkouts outside RedKey. The MCP package is planned as a separate sibling.
CHK-003	UX Spec Waiver	pass	A visual UX spec is not needed. Requirements and architecture define the tool interface and user-facing behavior.
CHK-004	Security Boundary	watch	The read-only filesystem tool is the highest-risk component and needs explicit path traversal and command allowlist tests.
CHK-005	Scope Control	pass	Complete scope includes semantic/hybrid search and application-source indexing, while preserving safe keyword-only operation and docs-first defaults.

review

status

approved_for_decomposition

summary

The project is coherent as a tooling/MCP project. UX_SPEC is intentionally omitted because the interface is MCP tool contracts, not a visual surface.

reviewer

atlas-codex

reviewed at

2026-05-01

project

oro-docs-mcp

name

Oro Documentation MCP

client id

redkey

source artifacts

intent

docs/projects/oro-docs-mcp/artifacts/INTENT.json

ux spec

No value captured.

architecture

docs/projects/oro-docs-mcp/artifacts/ARCHITECTURE.json

requirements

docs/projects/oro-docs-mcp/artifacts/REQUIREMENTS.json

intake triage

docs/projects/oro-docs-mcp/artifacts/INTAKE_TRIAGE.json

decision

notes

Proceed to DECOMP and PLAN. No implementation until EXEC_PLAN_REVIEW approves a build slice.

ready for build

false

ready for decomp

true

build requires exec approval

true

findings

id	issue	status	target	severity	required change
FIND-001	The filesystem query tool must be implemented with a strict allowlist and root confinement.	accepted	ARCHITECTURE CMP-004	medium	Plan M-02 and the evaluation module must include negative tests for traversal, absolute paths, and write-like commands.
FIND-002	RST parsing can be pragmatic in the complete implementation.	accepted	REQUIREMENTS F-02	low	Do not block the project on complete Sphinx resolution; preserve raw fallback chunks and track parser gaps through evaluation.

artifact type

COHERENCE_REVIEW

schema version

1.0